- Please visit our social media pages
Spain is facing legal action from the European Commission after failing to implement a European Union directive intended to simplify Impuesto sobre el Valor Añadido (IVA)rules for small businesses and self-employed workers.
The directive, which should have been incorporated into national law by 31 December 2024, introduces a framework allowing EU member states to exempt small businesses with low annual turnover from charging IVA. Spain has not yet transposed this directive into national legislation.
The EU Directive on IVA for Small Businesses
The relevant legislation is Directive (EU) 2020/285.
This directive amended the existing EU VAT system in order to simplify administrative requirements for small businesses operating within the European Union.
The directive allows member states to introduce a VAT exemption regime for small enterprises, under which businesses with an annual turnover of up to €85,000 may be exempt from charging IVA on their invoices.
The aim is to reduce the administrative burden for small businesses and freelancers by removing the need for VAT declarations, accounting requirements, and periodic reporting where turnover is relatively low.
Many EU countries have already introduced similar regimes.
Spain’s Failure to Transpose the Directive
Member states were required to transpose the directive into their national legal systems by 31 December 2024. Spain has not done so.
As a result, the European Commission has initiated infringement proceedings against Spain and referred the matter to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
This referral may ultimately lead to financial penalties if Spain is found to be in breach of its obligations under EU law.
Is Spain Obliged to Introduce the IVA Exemption?
An important legal point is that the directive does not oblige member states to introduce the IVA exemption domestically. The system is optional.
However, the directive still required all member states to transpose the framework into national law, particularly to ensure that small businesses operating cross-border within the EU can benefit from the exemption where applicable.
The European Commission’s legal action concerns Spain’s failure to transpose the directive at all, rather than simply its decision not to apply the exemption domestically.
Why Spain Has Not Implemented the System
Several reasons have been identified for Spain’s delay in implementing the directive.
Concerns about loss of tax revenue
Allowing small businesses to operate without charging VAT could significantly reduce IVA revenue. Spain has more than three million registered self-employed workers, and the Ministry of Finance has expressed concerns about the potential financial impact.
Risk of tax avoidance
Authorities have also raised concerns that businesses might restructure their activities in order to remain below the turnover threshold. For example, a larger business could theoretically divide its operations into several smaller entities to qualify for the exemption.
Spain already operates several simplified tax regimes for small businesses, including the módulos system and simplified IVA schemes. Introducing the EU framework could require changes to these existing structures, which are widely used in certain sectors.
These factors appear to have delayed the legislative process required to incorporate the directive into Spanish law.
What Happens Next
The case will now be considered by the Court of Justice of the European Union.
If the court rules that Spain has failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law, Spain may be required to implement the directive and could face financial sanctions.
At present, the IVA rules for self-employed workers in Spain remain unchanged. Autónomos must continue to charge and declare IVA in accordance with existing Spanish tax legislation.
